Halloween Smores Eyeballs - Easy Halloween Recipe (2024)

ByErin Reading Time: 4 minutes

Home » Eat » Halloween Smores Eyeballs – Easy Halloween Recipe

This post may contain affiliate links.Read the disclosure.

Our annual Halloween block party is approaching and I was trying to think of an easy potluck Halloween treat.

I came up with an idea for Halloween Smores that I decided to try today. It has been rainy all day, and something about the rain makes us want to bake.

Well, I wouldn’t really call this baking… or maybe I’d call it a baking shortcut.

Who loves s’mores? Just about everyone, right? These Smores Halloween eyeballs are made out of just Nilla Wafers, marshmallows, and chocolate chips.

I started with a very small batch because I wasn’t sure how they would turn out. Between my husband, boys, and I, they were gone in an instant.

Then, I made another batch, since the first was so successful. I placed them on a plate, took a few pictures, then put the plate on the counter.

I invited the kids to come downstairs and have a few s’mores eyeballs. Before I could finish the invitation, the s’mores were gone!

After reading this recipe, be sure to check out 13 Quick, Easy Halloween Treats Recipes.

Halloween Smores Eyeballs – Easy Halloween Treat

Don’t Miss These Ideas

• Avoid Upset Tummies With These Gluten-Free Halloween Treats
• Terrified Of Too Many Sweets? Try These Non-candy Halloween Treats!
• Kiss Cookies Recipe (without Peanut Butter) – Blossom Cookies No Nuts
• Kiss Cookies Recipe With Peanut Butter – Blossom Cookies

Ingredients To Make Halloween Smores

• Nilla Wafers (mini size)
• small marshmallows
• chocolate chips (any variety; we prefer milk chocolate)

Directions for Smores Eyeballs

• Preheat the oven to 300 degrees.
• Then, line a baking sheet with foil or parchment paper.
• Lay out the Nilla Wafters (however many you want) with about a half-inch or so between them. I prefer to place the wafers with the curved side up so they look more like rounded eyes.
• Next, on top of each wafer place a small marshmallow.
• Bake for about 5 minutes.
• Then, remove the baking sheet from the oven and carefullypress one chocolate chip on each marshmallow wafer. Press down to slightly smoosh the marshmallow and get the chocolate chip to stick.
• Return to the oven for about 1 minute.
• Next, let cool until the marshmallows and chocolate chips have hardened. This takes only a few minutes.
• Finally, eat if you dare!

For More Great Ideas, be sure to subscribe to our newsletter!

Other suggestions: If you truly want the s’mores taste you can use graham crackers. Either cut out your own circles or find some graham crackers already cut in circles.

Next Up From ChaChingQueen

• Kiss Cookies Recipe (without Peanut Butter) – Blossom Cookies No Nuts
• 13 Quick, Easy Halloween Treats Recipes
• Terrified Of Too Many Sweets? Try These Non-candy Halloween Treats!
• How to make the Best Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies. Soft and Fluffy
• How to Clean Oven with Vinegar and Baking Soda (and salt!)