I tried weight-loss app Noom again after a year—here’s what changed (2024)

I tried weight-loss app Noom again after a year—here’s what changed (1)

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission.

Ever since I wrote my first review of Noom, readers have emailed me privately to ask additional questions. Lately, the emails seem to have a theme: Have I kept off the weight since losing 20 pounds last year?

The short answer is yes, I have kept those 20 pounds off, even throughout the hot mess of 2020. And, in an attempt to take some control over a chaotic year, I volunteered to try it again in the fall. So I started Noom again at the beginning of October, mostly out of curiosity to see what people experience when they return. The 12 additional pounds I’ve lost is an added bonus. (To do the full math, that means I’ve lost a total of 32 pounds since beginning Noom in September 2019.)

Sign up for a trial of Noom.

What is Noom?

Noom is an app-based weight-loss program that uses lessons that rely on cognitive behavioral therapy techniques to help users follow a lower-calorie diet. The app itself is composed of a few basic features like weight tracking and food logging and a few upgraded features like a personal coach you can message directly, daily lessons that help reframe your thinking on food, and a group chat with fellow participants (which they refer to as “#NoomNerds”).

If you’re looking for a detailed overview of Noom, please click over to the original Noom review I wrote last year. There you’ll find a more comprehensive guide of the actual program. But if you’re wondering what happens after you go through the Noom program—and what it’s like if you return after a break—keep reading.

What’s it like to go back on Noom?

I tried weight-loss app Noom again after a year—here’s what changed (2)

There were very few discernible differences between using Noom for the first time and diving back in again. My original weight-loss graph was still there as was the food logging data I added during my first few months. All the custom meals I had added before were still available for me to choose again, and they still had the typos I stupidly made while entering them in the first place. (Please, Noom, let us edit custom meals!)

In addition to the food logging and weight tracking, Noom’s subscription serves up daily lessons, quizzes, and other light reading that are all aimed at helping users make the best choices for their eating habits. Many of the lessons I took the first time popped up again, and that repetitiveness made some smart wisdom seem trite. I did, however, appreciate that a number were obviously adjusted for a post-COVID world. (The daily lessons included fewer mentions about eating out at restaurants, for example.)

Basically, there was nothing new. If you used Noom before, you’ll know everything you’ll get for signing up again. That may come across as a criticism, but it's not meant as one. It also means that, if you were successful using Noom to lose weight before, there's a high likelihood that you'll be successful again.

What it is like to use Noom during the pandemic

For many people, 2020 was a year of lockdowns, social isolation, and quarantine during the COVID-19 pandemic. Turns out, that can be a good combination to help stick to a diet. It’s a lot easier to count calories when you’re making your meal from scratch instead of ordering from a restaurant. And, anyone working remotely from home can attest that it’s a lot easier to control the availability of snacks in your own kitchen than in the office breakroom.

How much does Noom cost when you sign up again?

The main differences between the first time I reviewed Noom and this last go-round was in the pricing structure. One early note here: I couldn’t quite tell if the difference was because they’re offering a different deal to all customers or if they offer different deals to returning ones. Noom does have a page where they list many of the current offerings and prices for each tier, but they do not make this list very well known. It seems that they prefer to share price options with users at the end of the sign-up process.

In 2019 when I first signed up for it, Noom offered a six-month signup for $150 after a two-week free trial. One caveat was that you had to watch the calendar to cancel after six months, otherwise you would get charged again, and you would immediately lose access to the subscriber benefits when you indicated that you wanted to cancel, so you couldn’t cancel early and ride out your time.

When I signed up again in the fall of 2020, my offer was different. I was offered (or “unlocked” in their terms) a free two-week trial (normally $40) and a waived “starter fee” (normally $20). In addition, the paid signup period was reduced from six months to three months for $129 (down from $180, the app claimed). One welcome change was that I could cancel my subscription early and keep access to all the group chat and lessons until my three months were up.

When I tried using a fake email address to sign up as a new user in January 2021, I was offered a six-month subscription for $159 (“down” from $360) and they waived the $20 starter fee. One interesting twist was that, instead of a free trial, Noom gave me four options to pay for the two-week “introductory period.” The options were $0.50, $3, $10, and $18.37. Noom noted in this lineup that the $18.37 figure was the “most popular choice” and the exact cost to “compensate our Noom employees for the trial.”

After I completed my initial program with Noom and before I started up again, I received periodic emails with offers to rejoin. The emails often included an option to rejoin Noom at “$19 per month,” but I did not investigate further to determine that exact pricing plan.

How do you cancel Noom?

I found that canceling Noom was a fairly easy process in early January 2021. About two weeks before my three-month subscription ended, I messaged my support coach saying that I did not want to be charged again. My message seemed to trigger some automatic actions because a chatbot seemed to take over from there. This seems to be a vast improvement from their past practices, which were apparently so frustrating that the CEO of Noom wrote a blog post apologiafocused on their cancellation and refund issues in the summer of 2020, For me, once I confirmed that I did not want to re-up for another three months, there was no other pushback or heavy sales tactics. Everything continued as normal until the day after my subscription ran out,

What happens after you cancelNoom?

I learned one of the more surprising tricks about using Noom after I canceled it for the first time: It turns out that Noom is pretty helpfuleven after you stop paying for it, in several different ways.

For one, the app itself retains much of its usefulness. Once your subscription expires, you can still access and add to the weight tracking and food logging parts of the app and keep track of your daily intake. All of your custom meals are saved and your weight graph continues to show your progress from when you first started the program. After you input your number, an automated message often tries to entice you back onto the paid program, but those messages can easily be tapped away. I logged on to the app the day after my subscription lapsed and was surprised by how much I could still input and how much historical data I could still see. You’re locked out of the group chat, and there are no more lessons to complete, but the key elements are still there.

And, perhaps of more value, those daily messages continue to resonate even though you don’t receive new ones anymore. Yes, they can be simplistic, but Noom works by helping you reframe your thought process around food. Those lessons stick.

Sign up for aNoom trial

The product experts atReviewedhave all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed onFacebook,Twitter, andInstagram for the latest deals, reviews, and more.

Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

I tried weight-loss app Noom again after a year—here’s what changed (2024)

FAQs

I tried weight-loss app Noom again after a year—here’s what changed? ›

Basically, there was nothing new. If you used Noom before, you'll know everything you'll get for signing up again. That may come across as a criticism, but it's not meant as one. It also means that, if you were successful using Noom to lose weight before, there's a high likelihood that you'll be successful again.

What has changed with Noom? ›

Noom adjusted its platform in August 2022 to acknowledge some people may experience negative emotions because of the scale. As a result, you decide how often you want to step on the scale. Yet the language in the daily lessons still encourages you to work toward daily weigh-ins.

What is the controversy with Noom? ›

Some Noom users say the app's daily weigh-ins and calorie-tracking system are 'toxic' and triggered disordered eating. The weight-loss app Noom built its brand on acknowledging that "diets don't work." Former users say they were drawn to Noom's message, but the app triggered disordered eating.

What are the complaints about Noom? ›

In addition to the auto-renewal and billing complaints, Noom faced criticism from experts and consumers for its weight loss program. While branding itself as different from other diets, the app has previously set very low calorie goals that dietitians say put users at risk of side effects.

What is the downside of Noom? ›

While Noom may be a good fit for some people, there are a few downsides. Most notably, Noom doesn't offer in-person interactions with coaches or other Noom members. The cost, concerns around low calorie goals, and potential pitfalls of food tracking are among other downsides of the program.

What do doctors say about Noom? ›

However, while Noom can serve you in the short term by helping you change your eating habits and practice mindful eating, some experts recommend against using weight-loss apps like Noom. "A strict diet protocol, or labeling foods in any way, isn't a healthy practice.

Can you rejoin Noom? ›

Yes, of course!

Why is there a lawsuit against Noom? ›

But in reality, Noom intentionally created a difficult cancellation process, so users who were unable to withdraw in time were instantly back charged for months of service. This “automatic enrollment trap” led to more than 1,000 complaints with the Better Business Bureau and ultimately the lawsuit. See Third Am. Compl.

Is Noom worth it in 2024? ›

Weight loss apps can be a structured and supportive way for people to learn how to make positive changes to their nutrition and exercise habits, but they aren't for everyone. We found that Noom does a great job promoting accountability, offering guidance and education, and encouraging healthy habits.

What is the gimmick with Noom? ›

Noom's diet recommendations are restrictive and hierarchical in a way that promotes disordered eating. When a user downloads Noom's app, it onboards them by asking them how much weight they want to lose and how fast they want to lose it.

What is an alternative to Noom? ›

1. Vegetable Bouillon Powder. If you are looking for a salty nutritional yeast substitute to add to a soup recipe, try using plant-based vegetable bouillon powder. You'll get the umami kick that nooch would bring to the recipe, without having to use nutritional yeast.

Why did Noom rebrand? ›

As a digital-first, consumer-led brand, Noom needed a clearly identifiable and recognizable symbol in addition to a re-tooled wordmark. The new symbol is a modern, dynamic interpretation of a compass.

What ever happened to Noom? ›

In 2022, Noom settled a lawsuit that alleged it had misled users into signing up for subscriptions that were difficult to cancel. In October, Bloomberg reported Noom had begun searching for a new CEO to replace cofounder Saeju Jeong, who will become executive chairman when a successor is named.

Why am I not losing weight with Noom? ›

Just like most weight loss programs, Noom relies on calorie counting, which often fails to sustain results long-term. When calories are restricted, the body's metabolism slows down as a natural response to conserve energy.

What is the most effective weight loss program out there? ›

Summary: Compare the Best Weight Loss Programs of 2024
ProductForbes Health RatingsLearn More
Weight Watchers (WW)5.0Learn More On Weight Watcher's Website
Noom Weight4.5Learn More On Noom's Website
Atkins5.0View More
The New Mayo Clinic DietLearn More On New Mayo Clinic Website
1 more row
Jun 4, 2024

Why doesn't Noom work? ›

While Noom doesn't tell you exactly what to eat, one big problem is the way it gives participants a calorie level to follow. Like many programs, that calorie level is too low, leading to a restrictive eating pattern to lose weight. When we say low — we mean low — around 1,200 calories per day.

Is Noom basically Weight Watchers? ›

Noom uses a color-coding system, while WW uses a points system to help steer you toward foods that are lower in calories and more nutritious. However, either program may be difficult to follow if you choose to incorporate more high fat foods — even those high in healthy fats — into your diet.

What is the secret to Noom weight loss? ›

Focus on your eating first

As Noom taught us, this is because about 90% of weight loss comes from a change in diet, and only about 10% comes from exercise. So for success with Noom when you start out, we suggest you focus your energy on what you're eating and on changing your behaviors and habits around food, first.

What is the success rate of Noom? ›

Some research suggests that Noom does help people lose weight. In one study, 78% of people lost weight while using Noom, and 23% lost more than 10% of their body weight. Dieting is hard, no matter what approach you take.

Does everyone get 1200 calories on Noom? ›

Minimum Calorie Range

To keep your body functioning at its best, Noom won't let those who identify as female adjust their goal below 1,200-1,320 calories per day, those who identify as male below 1,400-1,540 calories per day, and those who don't choose to select a binary gender below 1,200-1,320 calories per day.

What are the side effects of Noom? ›

Health Risks of Noom
  • Potential preoccupation with food thoughts from meal tracking.
  • Shame and body dissatisfaction possible with regular weigh-ins.
  • Could trigger disordered eating in vulnerable people.

What happens after a year on Noom? ›

Once your subscription expires, you can still access and add to the weight tracking and food logging parts of the app and keep track of your daily intake. All of your custom meals are saved and your weight graph continues to show your progress from when you first started the program.

How long do people stay on Noom? ›

The Noom plan is designed to last 16 weeks, but you're encouraged to buy up to twelve months at a time for weight loss and maintenance. To meet my goal of a 12-pound weight loss, my calorie budget was 1,250 calories a day for 16 weeks.

How to get Noom for free? ›

1 Now you can join Noom at no cost as part of your CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield (CareFirst) health plan benefits. CareFirst is focused on whole health and aims to meet the needs of our members in all aspects of their lives. That's why we've made Noom available through our well-being program.

Can I get Ozempic through Noom? ›

If you're still figuring out your weight journey, Noom Med can help you determine if Ozempic is right for you. If you qualify, you will be paired with a clinician who will speak to you about your goals, health, and all treatment options, including Ozempic.

What's the secret with Noom? ›

The diet is similar to a traffic light, so the green foods are good. They're actually so good Noom doesn't give you a calorie limit for the green foods. Noom even says, “The more Green the better!” You can make entire meals from only foods listed on the Green list: salads, mixed grain bowls, and tacos!

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gregorio Kreiger

Last Updated:

Views: 6364

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gregorio Kreiger

Birthday: 1994-12-18

Address: 89212 Tracey Ramp, Sunside, MT 08453-0951

Phone: +9014805370218

Job: Customer Designer

Hobby: Mountain biking, Orienteering, Hiking, Sewing, Backpacking, Mushroom hunting, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Gregorio Kreiger, I am a tender, brainy, enthusiastic, combative, agreeable, gentle, gentle person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.